Fall 2022

MatchBOX Community

Building online community spaces to augment and support a physical community

Current MBX Community

Observations

Throughout the semester, our group went to MatchBOX more than 20 times during the same time on various days of the week (11:30-1:20PM, our class time) for sponsor meetings, to observe, host events related to our Discord later, or just to have a good space to work. 

We were able to get relevant observational insights on the current community at MBX. While conversation would pick up a little during lunch time at the coffee bar, most people are working alone and don’t initiate conversation with other people because It’s hard to know if others are open to conversations while working. 

Overall, there was a lack of togetherness and community based on these observations. 

Community-Building Research

This project required the team to have knowledge of building and supporting communities in order to design around and suggest ways the MBX community could be revitalized. Because of this, for the first week, the team split up into different topics for secondary research. I worked with another team member researching community building online & in general

Screenshot of our research notes

Research Summary

  • There needs to be a team of highly motivated volunteers to start up the community with good and regularly posted content, and another team of dedicated and active moderators to communicate etiquette, roles, and help preserve the community (Kindsmüller et al., 2009)
Visual summary of the team's research; integrates order of conversation in online communities w/ other findings

Creating Social Opportunities for MBX Community

Discord Ideation

Our team split into groups of 2-3 to ideate on Discord channels. 

The focus was finding the best way to create a social category to increase the chances people will interact with each other online through commonalities and subsequently offline in the MBX space, too. Since MBX was a coworking space, all groups also included some variation of a separate professional category and category for MatchBOX space itself so our sponsors could make announcements. 

Whiteboard Sketch of potential channels w/ another team member

My team member Sam and I came up with these channels, focusing on onboarding and the social category. 

  • Our suggestion for a lunch & around-town channels got put in the Discord. 

The team eventually based most of the Discord Channel creation around this sketch by another pair.  

Whiteboard sketch of potential channels; most helpful for channel creation

Discord Channel Creation

Once we figured out what channels to create, we just moved straight into creating the Discord channels and put in sample messages in each one so that new members would be able to tell what they’re used for. 

Rationale for our Discord channels and categories: Start Here, MatchBOX, Makerspace
Rationale for our Discord channels and categories: Social, Interest Channels, and Professional Corner

Testing the Discord

Discord Responses 

Our Discord design worked in that MBX members were able to get to know each other more online and interacted regularly on the server during the project. 

Many members posted in #introductions, #pets, and in #recommendations with book recommendations to each other. These were more easy, minimal effort social interactions.

Example of UX members' introductions in #introductions leading to MBX members creating introductions and even conversations in the channel
Example of UX members' prepopulated messages in #pets helping MBX members feel comfortable with posting too
Screenshot of an easy poll a UX member conducted that got MBX members' interactions

On the other side, people didn’t use the professional corner that we created. This may be due to the fact that we didn’t prepopulate it for fear of unintentionally signaling “only designers can post here” as we were all UX design students. Or it could tie into our previous research that people just wanted to be social. 

While we recruited early adopters to facilitate and start conversation, the UX team did the most facilitation of conversations on the Discord and there were only a few early adopters that were active on the server. This made it difficult as we didn’t want the server to seem like a server for us UX students.

Early Adopters Event

Towards the end of the semester, the team hosted an early adopters event to have an in-person discussion with the early adopters about our Discord and recommendations we had. We planned to ask them questions on the Discord but they didn’t answer, and it turned out hosting an in-person event was good for getting detailed thoughts and opinions. 

It was also good for getting perspectives from members who weren’t on the Discord to find out how we could make it more accessible to them

Our overall insights were:

  • Barriers to entry as members didn’t know what Discord was / weren’t interested in social media
  • Barriers to posting and interaction; members were uncomfortable with posting and interacting when other members didn’t
  • Lack of staff interaction on the server
  • Lack of members online
  • Members are are unsure how to use certain channels 

Onboarding

Discord onboarding

Many people from the early adopters event didn’t even know what Discord was but were open to it once they found out about it. We created a Discord onboarding presentation for general members and another transition document for staff.

We were planning on hosting another event specifically for onboarding, but because this was towards the end of the semester and we were running out of time, we decided to hand off the finished onboarding presentation to our sponsors so they could host their own

Entire presentation

 

My slides for the onboarding presentation

Impact

At the end of the semester, we needed to wrap up and summarize the project with a final presentation and documentation for details on our design process, design rationale, outcomes, and future recommendations for our sponsor.

Final Team Presentation

Unfortunately, after the semester ended… 

Screenshots of inactive MBX discord

The UX team only worked with MBX during the semester that we were in charge of the Discord, so we stopped facilitating and sending messages to encourage conversations after our final presentation. Once we did that however, there weren’t many messages sent since then, so the server is inactive save for the QOTD Bot. 

Hopefully MBX will be able to use our final suggestions to host their own onboarding event to use and launch this server again in the future. While it lasted, there were really great interactions among members that were active and even between a staff member that was active on the server and members. 

reflection

Challenges and Next Steps

  • Launching and making sure the members were active on the server was difficult; we didn’t want to create an inactive and dead server that would render Discord unviable to the MBX community forever 
  • Difficulty getting in contact with interviewees and Discord members online, we found through the early adopters event it was much easier get people to participate in-person

If we had more time...